header photo

Friday, February 10, 2012

The Latest Rankings on Paint Brands

 
Source: Aircanada

The discussion of paint brands is always a hot topic and often a hotly debated subject in this industry. Whether you are asking designers, painting contractors or homeowners, there's a variety of opinions. Not everyone is aware that there are a few different official rankings available that are based on testing and criteria. 

The three I frequently look at are JD Powers, Consumer Reports and Good Housekeeping. While JD Powers ranks consumer satisfaction, Consumer Reports and Good Housekeeping rank paint brands based on testing. Unless you're a color nerd, it can be a bit daunting to sift through the data to filter out the overall results.


For example, my latest issue of Consumer Reports (March 2012) tested various paint lines from 13 different major brands, ranking by 3 sheen's and challenging:

Hiding
Stains
Gloss change
Scrubbing
Smoothness 
Mildew Resistance
Resisting Sticking (tackiness when dry)
Fading
VOC levels


In 2012, Benjamin Moore edged out Behr which held all three top ranks in 2011. Benjamin Moore came in first for Satin/Eggshell as well as in the Semi-gloss category. Consumer Reports states they've seen a steady improvement over the years in Benjamin Moore's quality but Behr remains the best value for what you get money-wise. Blue checks were also given for overall good values for the quality in different paint brands.


Here are the rankings for the top 4 in 2012:

Satin/Eggshell

Benjamin Moore Aura (Up from #6 last year)
Behr Premium Plus Ultra Satin Enamel ( 1st Place last year)
Kilz Brand (Stayed in #3 spot from 2011)
Glidden Premium Satin (Down from #3 last year)

Flat and Matte

Behr (Premium Plus Ultra ) Same rank as 2011
Benjamin Moore's Aura Matte ( up from 7th place last year)
Behr's Premium Plus Flat Enamel (#2 last year for Behr)
Benjamin Moore's Natura Flat (3rd Place in 2011)

Semigloss

Benjamin Moore's Regal Select (jump from #7 last year)
Behr's Premium Plus (Held at #2 spot)
Benjamin Moore's Aura (Huge jump from #13 last year)
Royal Interiors by ACE ( Up one spot from #5 in 2011)

Bottom rankings in all three categories goes to Color Place by Walmart.



Good Housekeeping ranks paints differently ….......This data is harder to sift through compared to Consumer Reports and it's fuzzy regarding how many paints were tested overall. Less precise rankings were given besides letter grades and a conclusion of pro versus cons in the resulting 25 that they listed.

Good Housekeeping 2011

The test process was explained for achieving the following tests:

Splatter Resistance
Scratch Resistance
Drying Time
Coverage Area
Coverage Quality
UV Resistance
Stain Removal
Color Consistency
Overall Quality and Texture

A grades went to:
Freshaire
PPG Pure Performance (Eggshell)
Dutch Boy Interior Semi-Gloss
Ace Royal Interior Flat

JD Powers and Associates 2011 Consumer Rankings





These rankings were based on 6 criteria from consumers/homeowners only for 19 major paint brands:

Application
Production Offerings
Durability
Price
Design Guidelines
Warranty

Benjamin Moore came out as the stand alone winner while Porter Paints and Sherwin Williams came in second and third reflectivity. At the bottom of the heap were Color Place (Walmart), Martha Stewart (Surprise!) Glidden, Olympic, True Value and Ace paints. 




When I analyze the plethora of data and the fact that:

1. Not all paint brands were included in all rankings.

2. Consumer Reports and Good Housekeeping listed different criteria and ultimately conducted testing in different ways.



Ace: All over the place with higher rankings through Consumer Reports and Good Housekeeping but below average points with JD Powers.



Behr: Middle rankings with Good Housekeeping and JD Powers but high marks with Consumer Reports.



Benjamin Moore: ranked top in both JD Powers as well as Consumer Reports although the Aura, Regal and Ben paint lines only scored in the B grade ranges for Good Housekeeping. You're not going to find too many colorists who don't use this line as one of the back bones of their paint and color preferences.


Glidden: This was all over the place! While placing well in most of Consumer Reports 2012 rankings, they placed a B grade in Good Housekeeping and below average with JD Power.



Kelly Moore: The darling of painting contractors in my area, Kelly Moore only appeared in the JD Powers reviews and ranked average in all criteria but above average in durability.

Olympic: Wide ranging reviews again from middling to low reviews in latest Consumer Reports, B grades from Good Housekeeping to poor reviews from consumers for JD Powers.




Sherwin Williams: While receiving lower reviews from Consumer Reports, they received high marks from consumers in the JD Powers rankings. No published reviews from the latest Good Housekeeping latest list.



Valspar: Middle of the road reviews from all three rankings.



Bottom of the heap: True Value received middle lower to downright bad scores over all three ranking systems while Walmart's ColorPlace came in last place with Consumer Reports and JD Powers but are not in Good Housekeeping's latest rankings.


Hey I'm only the messenger on this but I do love asking my clients and painter for their experiences with paint brands. Many of the other paints reviewed only appeared in one of the rankings so I didn't delve into them. Where do YOU stand on paint brands? What are your experiences?

7 comments:

Kelly Berg said...

wow. that's a lot of info! so many paint brands, it can make your head spin! aura is one of my favorites, no doubt. i'll make a note to stay far far away from Color Place (not that I have ever been tempted to spec or use it!)

thanks, Marie!

Kelly @ JAX does design said...

I'm not loyal to any particular paint brand. I've had good results with Behr, Benjamin Moore, Sherwin Williams, ICI, and Sico (LOVE Sico Cashmere matte finish). I had a bad experience with CIL paint, but that may have been because I put tape on the wall to paint stripes without letting the fresh coat of paint dry long enough. The only paint I've been truly disappointed with is Farrow & Ball. It's almost too thick, and it splatters like crazy (in my experience, anyway). Given how much it costs, I'd say it isn't very good value for the money.

Rachel said...

what a great review! it's really hard to dissect all the information about one paint brand to the next. I think my biggest deciding factor is color palette- if they have a well balanced palette of beautiful colors, i'm hooked. The second factor is location. When I lived on the east coast, SW stores were everywhere, and so it was easier for clients to obtain than other brands. Out here in the Bay Area, its all BM. So I use them the most. If a client can't get the paint easily, there's no point in spec'ing it.

Marie Brady said...

I've never had the chance to use Farrow and Ball but have admired their books. But that's good to know as I'd be bummed to use such a pricey paint and get those result too, Kelly.

So true about palettes and availability Rachel! Also what they provide for the design trade helps greatly.

Elizabeth Brown said...

Thank you, Marie for sifting through all this information for us. I wasn't aware of Behr's high rating and will now take a gander at their palette.

I'm with Rachel. I spec color for color's sake, so I have faves with Benjamin Moore, Sherwin Williams and C2, all of which are excellent quality and user friendly to the color consultant in their accommodation.

Donna Frasca said...

I can vouch for Behr Paint. I have it in my home, love the colors, quality and the price! Great article in Consumer Reports.

Anonymous said...

What have you heard about Rustoleum paints? I see a larger prescence of that brand in my neighborhood stores.